When His Honour Judge John Potter was named Chair of the public inquiry into Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust (TEWV), his appointment was welcomed by families and individuals affected by failings at TEWV.

HHJ Potter will oversee the independent statutory inquiry examining serious concerns about mental health care at TEWV. It is a role that will require him to navigate clinical evidence, institutional decision-making, conflicting accounts and, most importantly, the experiences of individuals and families whose lives sit behind the evidence.

From solicitor to senior judge: John Potter’s legal career

HHJ Potter’s full name is Roderick John Conwy Potter.

Unlike judges who began their careers as barristers, HHJ Potter entered the profession as a solicitor. He was admitted in 1987 and qualified as a Higher Court Advocate a decade later.

His career then increasingly moved towards judicial and regulatory work.

In 1997, he became a member of the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal. He was appointed a Recorder in 2005 and became a Circuit Judge in 2010.

Four years later, he took on a significant leadership position as Resident Judge at Manchester Crown Court at Minshull Street, remaining in that role until 2022.

In 2018, HHJ Potter was authorised to sit in the Criminal Division of the Court of Appeal.

He retired from the Circuit Bench on 1 November 2025.

Throughout his career, HHJ Potter has held a number of senior judicial and leadership roles, giving him extensive experience in governance, the administration of justice and the management of complex organisations. Many of the matters he has dealt with during his career have involved sensitive issues, vulnerable individuals and bereaved families, experiences which are likely to be relevant to the work of the Inquiry.

His experience also includes involvement in inquiries, reviews and wider public accountability processes, providing a valuable background for leading a statutory public inquiry of this nature.

Why appoint a judge to investigate an NHS mental health trust?

His job is to lead an independent process capable of establishing facts from evidence.

Many of those involved to date have welcomed the appointment of HHJ John Potter. After years of investigations, reviews and unanswered questions, there is reassurance in knowing that the Inquiry will be led by someone whose role is to independently examine the evidence, test competing accounts and ensure that important facts are not overlooked.

Participants are looking for a process that is thorough, impartial and capable of getting to the heart of what happened. A judge-led inquiry provides confidence that evidence will be examined rigorously, difficult questions will be asked and conclusions will be based on the evidence rather than assumptions.

Those involved have taken reassurance from HHJ Potter’s appointment, recognising his extensive experience in carefully examining complex evidence and leading substantial judicial processes. They hope this will help ensure that difficult issues are approached with focus and rigour, and that important evidence is not overlooked.

Clinical experts will play an important role in helping the Inquiry understand mental health care and treatment decisions. The Chair’s role is different. It is to ensure that all of the evidence is fairly and carefully considered, that organisations and witnesses are properly scrutinised, and that the Inquiry reaches independent conclusions that command public confidence.

The significance of Potter’s first decision: listening before defining

One of the most revealing aspects of HHJ Potter’s appointment is not something contained in his CV.

It is what he said he would do first.

On his appointment, HHJ Potter made clear that he intended to meet and listen to people affected by the matters the inquiry will examine. He also indicated that their experiences would inform the development of the inquiry’s Terms of Reference.

That may sound procedural. It isn’t.

The Terms of Reference will determine the scope of the inquiry: what it is expected to investigate and, by implication, what sits outside its formal remit.

For individuals who have campaigned for scrutiny of TEWV, those boundaries could be enormously important.

HHJ Potter also emphasised that the Inquiry would approach its work independently, thoroughly and fairly, and with respect for everyone who participates.

What powers will Judge Potter have?

The TEWV investigation is a statutory public inquiry and is established under the Inquiries Act 2005. It has formal mechanisms for obtaining evidence. The inquiry can compel people to attend to give evidence and can compel the production of documents, subject to the statutory framework.

That means HHJ Potter will be leading a process with powers that a non-statutory inquiry or an independent review does not possess. Importantly, those powers are not limited to current employees of the Trust. Former executives, clinicians, managers and other individuals who may hold relevant evidence can also be required to provide information or attend to give evidence where the Inquiry considers it necessary.

The Chair can require witnesses to answer questions and can receive evidence on oath or affirmation. This provides the Inquiry with a powerful mechanism for testing evidence, examining differing accounts, understanding who knew what and when, and exploring whether opportunities to identify and address concerns were missed.

A public inquiry is a fact-finding exercise. It is not a criminal court and it does not exist to determine a person’s civil or criminal liability.

HHJ Potter’s eventual conclusions can identify what happened, examine institutional or systemic problems and make recommendations. Whilst the Inquiry cannot itself impose civil or criminal sanctions, its findings may identify failings, expose shortcomings in decision-making, and provide a detailed public account of events and the actions of those responsible. Other legal, regulatory and disciplinary processes have different functions and may consider such findings where appropriate.

Understanding that distinction will become increasingly important as the TEWV Inquiry progresses. For many families and individuals, however, the statutory powers available to the Chair provide reassurance that witnesses can be questioned, documents can be obtained, and important evidence can be scrutinised in a way that would not be possible through a non-statutory review.

What happens next?

The Inquiry remains in its early stages and a great deal of work is still to be undertaken before public hearings begin. The Chair will first need to consider the Terms of Reference, which will determine the scope of the Inquiry, the issues to be examined and the period of time under investigation.

Participants are hoping that the Inquiry will be broad in scope and examine events spanning a number of years, allowing it to identify not only individual incidents but also any wider cultural, governance or systemic issues that may have developed over time.

The appointment of HHJ John Potter has been widely welcomed by those affected. Individuals recognise that a statutory public inquiry of this scale will be a lengthy and detailed process and have taken reassurance from the Judge’s willingness to undertake that responsibility. There is hope that the Inquiry will deliver a thorough examination of the issues raised and contribute to meaningful and lasting improvements in mental health services.

Whilst the Inquiry will focus on TEWV, many of the issues being discussed are not unique to a single organisation. Participants therefore hope that the Inquiry’s findings and recommendations will not only improve services for those who access care within TEWV, but will also help to strengthen mental health services more widely and influence national policy and practice for years to come.

Find out more about the TEWV inquiry.